Pro research

Maker (MKR) Price to Burn Analysis: Still "relatively expensive" to peer group as investors continue to pay a massive premium for a credit facility

DeFi Protocols•November 5, 2019, 1:54AM EST
UPDATED: March 16, 2022, 3:45PM EDT
Maker (MKR) Price to Burn Analysis: Still "relatively expensive" to peer group as investors continue to pay a massive premium for a credit facility

Quick Take

  • Maker (MKR) trailing 12 month Price to Burn multiple has rationalized from +2000x in early 2019; but is still at +200x 
  • This compares to Binance’s trailing 12 mo Price-to-Burn of ~35x, and an estimated trailing 12 mo Price to Earnings (PE) of ~6x; which isn’t exposed to nearly as much credit risk 
  • Binance estimated trailing 12 month Price-to-Earnigns (P/E) puts it well underneath the ~15x P/E traditional brokers (ICE, Schwab, Nasdaq, E*Trade, etc.) currently trade at

With the help of explicit "earnings" data within the Maker system — visible via smart contracts on the Ethereum blockchain and courtesy of data from Marc-André Dumas — we re-calculated relative valuation metrics for Maker such as Price to Burn (Interest Earnings) and Earnings Yield (Burn Yield) through the third quarter of 2019. Our findings show that although Maker has achieved a fairly stable peg with its stablecoin DAI (daily price standard deviation of $.015 since Jan 2018), the system hasn't been able to capture and distribute interest payments (revenue) to its MKR stakeholders adequate to its current total market value, relative to a peer group (i.e. investors are paying a massive premium in terms of price to burn, and for a credit facility exposed to credit risks no less!).

Expert insights. Delivered.

Get access to a suite of news, research, data, and funding tools