Republicans ask Justice Department, SEC to investigate Prometheum

Quick Take

  • Republican lawmakers, led by Sen. Tommy Tuberville, want the Justice Department and Securities and Exchange Commission to look into Prometheum’s statements around Chinese investment.
  • The company became subject of increased scrutiny after its co-CEO testified before a House committee last month, arguing that digital asset firms can operate within current securities laws.

A group of Republican lawmakers wants the Justice Department and Securities and Exchange Commission to investigate digital asset firm Prometheum, whose co-CEO Aaron Kaplan testified before a House committee as a Democratic witness at a hearing on crypto-related legislation last month. 

Prometheum recently gained approval from the SEC as an alternative trading system, with Kaplan testifying in June that he wanted to build a crypto trading platform that operated within existing securities laws a message in line with the SEC's approach since it began cracking down on initial coin offerings as unregistered securities in 2017. That view cuts against much of the digital asset industry, which argues that blockchain-based assets should not be subject to the same investment rules as other businesses. The firm has been subject to increased scrutiny since Kaplan's appearance. 

Now several Republicans on the committee, as well as a senator uninvolved in the hearing, want the Justice Department and SEC to investigate the company.

"Making false statements to Congress is a crime. Submitting false or misleading statements in SEC filings constitutes securities fraud," write the House and Senate Republicans.

Prometheum’s relationship to Hashkey under scrutiny

During last month's hearing Republicans questioned Kaplan about Prometheum's business operations, including Chinese investment. Now they want an investigation into whether Prometheum mischaracterized its relationship with overseas investors in statements to the SEC and Congress.

Sen. Tommy Tuberville, R-Ala., led the letter, and took issue with what he said is Prometheum’s largest outside investor — China-based company Shanghai Wanxiang Blockchain, Inc. and its subsidiary HashKey Digital Asset Group, Ltd., one of the largest crypto firms in Asia. Reps. Blaine Luetkemeyer, R-Mo., Barry Loudermilk, R-Ga., Ralph Norman, R-S.C., Byron Donalds, R-Fla., and Mark Alford, R-Mo., also signed the letter.

“These ties are deeply concerning to each of us and to many of our colleagues in Congress,” the lawmakers said in their letter on Monday. Most of the House Republicans signing onto the letter are members of the House Financial Services Committee, which has jurisdiction over the SEC. But most Republicans on the committee did not sign the letter.

In an emailed statement, Kaplan said Prometheum did not “misrepresent” the firm’s relationship with Wanxiang and said he never said that its “joint development” with Wanxiang ended in December 2019.

“We determined in early 2020 the co-development of technology was not viable and in order to avoid corporate and litigation risk, sought to create value from our relationship," Kaplan said in the statement provided by a spokesperson. “In its written testimony, Prometheum clearly states that joint development with Wanxiang and its affiliates formally ended in October 2021.” During the hearing, Kaplan said that all servers, code, data and proprietary technology were created by Prometheum independently of Wanxiang.

Kaplan also fired back at the letter requesting an investigation. 

"Prometheum’s ongoing efforts to achieve a compliant digital asset securities ecosystem will not be derailed by partisan and specious allegations."

Tuberville's public scrutiny of Prometheum began prior to Kaplan's appearance in the House. Before the mid-June hearing Tuberville raised concerns about Promethem’s ties to China before in a June 5 letter to the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, which approved Prometheum as a special purpose broker dealer, and the SEC.

Those concerns were “unfounded and without merit,” Kaplan said in his prepared testimony before the House Financial Services Committee last month. Hashkey made an investment into Prometheum in 2018, and Prometheum and Wanxiang entered into a “development agreement,” Kaplan said, but added that a year later it became clear that “joint development was not viable.” 

Republicans signing the letter cast skepticism on that statement. 

“If Prometheum began developing its own technology platform totally independent of its China-based, CCP-tied partners in December 2019 as Mr. Kaplan attempted to lead Congress to believe in his congressional testimony, why was this not made clear in Prometheum’s SEC filings,” the lawmakers said. 

In their request for an investigation, which the DOJ and SEC do not have to comply with, the lawmakers ask for "prompt attention to our concerns," but do not provide a deadline for a response.


UPDATE: With a statement from Kaplan. 

© 2023 The Block. All Rights Reserved. This article is provided for informational purposes only. It is not offered or intended to be used as legal, tax, investment, financial, or other advice.